First Night: Reading and Leeds festivals - The Independent

The formatter threw an exception while trying to deserialize the message: Error in deserializing body of request message for operation 'Translate'. The maximum string content length quota (30720) has been exceeded while reading XML data. This quota may be increased by changing the MaxStringContentLength property on the XmlDictionaryReaderQuotas object used when creating the XML reader. Line 1, position 33775.
First Night: Reading and Leeds festivals - Reviews - Music - The IndependentTuesday 28 August 2012i Jobs Dating Property Shop News Opinion Sport Paralympics Life Property Arts & Ents Art News Features Reviews Great Works Architecture Music News Features Reviews Classical News Features Reviews Films News Features Reviews TV & Radio News Features Reviews Theatre & Dance News Features Reviews Comedy News Features Reviews Books News Features Reviews Puzzles and Games Festival No.6 Travel Money IndyBest Blogs Student Hot TopicsGeorge OsborneSyriaGreeceMichael GoveArts & Ents >Music >Reviews First Night: Reading and Leeds festivals3.00

Same old Reading list, but still a rite of passage

Nick HastedMonday 27 August 2012

Tweet!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");Print Your friend's email address Your email address Note: We do not store your email address(es) but your IP address will be logged to prevent abuse of this feature. Please read our Legal Terms & PoliciesAAAEmailLatest in ReviewsCharli XCX. Sebright Arms, London
The Joy Formidable, The Lexington, LondonAlbum: Elis Regina, In London (Soul Jazz)Album: Robert Cray Band, Nothin' But Love (Provogue/Mascot)Album: Swans, The Seer (Young God)Album: Tango Crash, Accidente de Tango (Galileo Music)Album: Dan Deacon, America (Domino)Album: Enrico Rava, Rava On The Dance Floor (ECM)Album: Non Hendryx, Mutatis Mutandis (Righteous Babe)Album: Noisettes, Contact (Mono-ra-rama)News in picturesArts & Ents blogsVoewood: Sex, suburbia and the Leveson inquiryFrom The Fall of the House of Murdoch to The Buddha of Suburbia in a day packed with literature and ...

The Photography Blog: What’s the reality of becoming a DSLR user? Are we aware we might be getting into more than we bargained for?Among the photographers I meet, there is an overriding sense that DSLR’s give us a sense that we hav...

Voewood: A sparkling weekend of literatureA long, louche country house party loaded with literary discussion and liberally lubricated with gin

div.slideshow img {display: none;}.galleria-image-nav {display: none;}div.slideshow .galleria-stage {top: 0px;}div.slideshow .galleria-info {top: 10px;}div.slideshow .galleria-counter {display: none !important;}div.slideshow #slideshow-7804719 .galleria-thumbnails-container {height: 70px;bottom: 0;position: absolute;left: 10px;right: 10px;z-index: 2;}div.slideshow #slideshow-7804719 .galleria-container .galleria-stage {height: 445px;}div.slideshow #slideshow-7804719 .galleria-thumbnails .galleria-image {height: 60px;width: 60px;background: #000;margin: 0 5px 0 0;border: 1px solid #000;;float: left;cursor: pointer;}div.slideshow #slideshow-7804719 .galleria-counter {bottom: 83px !important;}.galleria-lightbox-image img { border-width:0; }Related articles

It's time for Britpop's Bright Young Things to take centre stage

Your guide to 2010's best festivals

Green Day, Shepherd’s Bush Empire, London

The Strokes and Muse headline Reading and Leeds Festivals

Trending: Green Day light a candle in the wind for Amy

Suggested TopicsSingersKasabianOasisAgeing

This year’s Reading bill looks over-familiar from top to bottom, faithfully reflecting a rock scene desperately waiting for new heroes. Foo Fighters, Kasabian and The Cure aren’t headliners to quicken the blood; the latter first played here in 1979. But Reading’s importance in comparison to upstart, upmarket boutique affairs still feels strong. It remains the muddy field where young people first get off the leash and off their faces to music.

“Hi, honey, I’m home,” the Foo Fighters’ Dave Grohl leers on Sunday, at the festival that fits him best. His most infamous Reading appearance remains Nirvana’s swansong 20 years ago, with Kurt Cobain in a wheelchair. This three-hour blow-out is more wholesome hard rock with every edge smoothed off, like being bludgeoned with a toy hammer. Stuttering, contemplative passages in songs such as “Breakout” barely slow their relentless, quickly redundant stride.

Midwest blues-rockers The Black Keys, preceding the Foos, could at their most ordinary have played Reading in 1972. “Nova Baby”’s staccato soul swing is among the recent songs giving them saving, danceable grace. 

Kasabian are received as a triumph on Saturday, but singer Tom Meighan comes across as an ageing Oasis fan, not a rock star. Their hollow empire is doomed to fall. Before them, Florence + the Machine are inspired by wild weather, singer Florence, in a fishnet body-suit, finishing rain-streaked and happy. Friday’s headliners The Cure take up 150 minutes, and Robert Smith is in wonderful voice. But “In Between Days”’s delicacy of feeling doesn’t last, during a set whose length smashes holes in the crowd.

Green Day’s surprise gig at 11am on Saturday, as many festival-goers slumber, is the nearest thing to an event. Equivalent punk power, though, is available in the Lock Up tent throughout the weekend. This is where Reading’s rock heart beats, indifferent to trends and headliners. Pittsburgh’s Anti-Flag dedicate The Clash’s “Should I Stay Or Should I Go” to Pussy Riot and Joe Strummer. They’re followed by California’s Social Distortion, Green Day grandfathers who began in 1978. Only singer Mike Ness remains from then, a soft-spoken elder statesman, his anger now worn and restrained. Their cow-punk version of Johnny Cash’s “Ring of Fire” is one festival peak.

Graham Coxon, back to his solo day job after Blur’s big day out at Hyde Park, finds the most creative response to rock’s history, gently bending and pulling apart The Who’s hard R’n’B on “Feel Alright”, and finishing with “I Don’t Wanna Go On”’s strange, bucking take on country-blues.

In a festival mostly geared to music’s passive consumption, Anti-Flag suggest the punk gig experience is an ideal of responsible yet fiercely individual living. Peckham’s Katy B offers a similar philosophy for dance music, and post-rave and pop sounds which would once have been urine-bottled off here are now part of Reading. Look no further than Lady Lykez’s hilarious paen to the weave, “Not My Hair”.

Edinburgh’s Django Django, too, combine wistful vocals, tribal drums and techno synths to become a sort of rave Franz Ferdinand, capable of constant surprise. Swedish-American freaks Miike Snow, meanwhile, deploy ecstatic dance music clichés with cosmic intent, on “The Devil’s Work” recalling Mercury Rev.

The Vaccines are part of the current British rock scene’s problem, all defeatist, ironic disaffection. The lie to that can still be found on the outer stages at night, where The Cribs offer advice to live by at Reading. “Get piercings, set fire to your tent,” orders singer Ryan Jarman. Then he adds, with faith defying current facts: “This is the best festival.”

Tweet!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");CommentsMore inReviews »Independent Commentblog comments powered by DisqusPlease provide search keyword(s)

Advanced Search Day in a page Article archive Most CommentedMost ViewedMost Shared1First she lost her boyfriend Robert Pattinson, now Kristen Stewart has lost her big part2Album: Calexico, Algiers City (Slang)3Who will play Christian Grey? Gosling is bookies' favourite for 50 Shades of Grey heartthrob4Comedian Dies in the Middle of a Joke, Pleasance Dome, Edinburgh5Meet the stars of Scorsese’s new blockbuster6The talent myth: How to maximise your creative potential7First Night: Reading and Leeds festivals8Dallas: Just when you thought it was safe to go back on the ranch...9Paralympics: Pomp, ceremony... and possibly well-played, Coldplay10Last night's viewing - Citizen Khan, BBC1 Hunderby, Sky Atlantic 1Sealed for 99 years and 363 days - so what was inside the mysterious parcel left to a small town in Norway?2'Why I'll never take the Pill again'3We'll make a killing out of food crisis, Glencore trading boss Chris Mahoney boasts4Cheerleader must compensate school that told her to clap 'rapist'5The (worst-kept) secret is out: Jeremy Clarkson had an injunction6Laurie Penny: It's nice to think that only evil men are rapists - that it's only pantomime villains with knives in alleyways. But the reality is different7Vigilante mob attacks home of paediatrician8The Hermione Granger effect: why teenagers are finally starting to say no to drugs and alcohol9'Hello mum, this is going to be hard for you to read ...'10‘Devastated’ Ennis falls victim to gold robbery div.carousel.commercial {height:355px;}SPONSORED FEATURES Experience the Heineken Hub

Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.

SuperhumanSwiss holidayNetworking 2012AirbnbThe O2 Prizes & offersBusiness videos Win a guided tour of Superhuman

With dinner for two and a £50 book token for the intriguing exhibition at the Wellcome Collection.

Heineken HubSwiss holidayNetworking 2012AirbnbThe O2 Prizes & offersBusiness videos Win your very own tailor-made holiday to Switzerland

Whether you'd rather hike up a mountain or relax in a spa, you'll love this trip to Graubünden.

Heineken HubSuperhumanNetworking 2012AirbnbThe O2 Prizes & offersBusiness videos A legacy we can be proud of

The most lasting effect London 2012 will have is to motivate children all over the UK to get interested in science, technology, engineering and maths

Heineken HubSuperhumanSwiss holidayAirbnbThe O2 Prizes & offersBusiness videos Looking to make extra cash this summer?

London will be busy this summer, so why not rent your house, flat or spare room with Airbnb?

Heineken HubSuperhumanSwiss holidayNetworking 2012The O2 Prizes & offersBusiness videos Now showing at the O2

Check out the cool stuff happening under our tent: the hottest gigs, comedy, sport, films, clubs, bars, restaurants and much more.

Heineken HubSuperhumanSwiss holidayNetworking 2012AirbnbPrizes & offersBusiness videos Enter the latest Independent competitions

Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.

Heineken HubSuperhumanSwiss holidayNetworking 2012AirbnbThe O2 Business videos Business videos from commercial thought leaders

Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.

Heineken HubSuperhumanSwiss holidayNetworking 2012AirbnbThe O2 Prizes & offers.iJobs-ctr {background:#F3F3F3;border:1px solid #ccc;border-top:8px solid lightGrey;margin:0 0 12px 0;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs-head {margin:10px;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs-head img {border: 0px none;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs {padding:0 10px;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs .header {display:none;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs .content ul {list-style: none;padding:0;margin:0;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs .content ul li {font-size:0.9em;margin: 5px 0;padding: 0 0 5px 0;border-bottom: 1px solid #DDD;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs .content ul li a {font-weight: bold;font-family: Arial, sans-serif;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs-ftr {margin:0 !important;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs-ftr .iJobsLinks {padding:5px 5px 5px 10px;margin:10px 0 0 0;background-color:lightGrey;}.iJobs-ctr .iJobs-ftr .iJobsLinks a {font-size:0.9em;}iJobs GeneralLand ManagerNQT or QTS Business Studies TeacherSales Applications EngineerHead of MediaQTS or NQT English TeacherView the latest from iJobsDay In a PageSunMonTueWedThuFriSat12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031JanuaryFebruaryMarchAprilMayJuneJulyAugustSeptemberOctoberNovemberDecember199219931994199519961997199819992000200120022003200420052006200720082009201020112012 The 10 Best clothes dryers From tried and tested old-fashioned designs to high-tech super dryers 'Actors want to act so I give them a platform to do it' Tyler Shields has no shortage of Hollywood names wanting to pose in crazy scenarios Just when you thought it was safe to go back on the ranch... A reboot of Dallas has defied all expectations – and some critics – to become the surprise hit of the summer Tea and mortality People who attend 'death cafes' just want to meet up and talk about something which will happen to us all The kids are all out Would you let your children play in the street? Special report: The empire strikes back Rupert Murdoch delivered an anti-establishment punch with The Sun’s naked photos of Prince Harry Robert Fisk The bloody truth about Syria's uncivil war Alistair Darling interview He's back... but did he ever go away? Ghana's witch camps Last refuge of the powerless and the persecuted John Rentoul: Forget Dave and George. The real story is the two Eds Speculation about the Chancellor's future is wide of the mark and ignores deeper cracks at the top of the Opposition I have a confession to make: I go to church Andrew Martin applauds a new report that says religion makes people happier, denies that religion is irrational, and wonders why his friends are so resistant to it Rupert Cornwell: Out of America Time for Romney to show if he's got what it takes The Paralympic Games have come home... ... And, my, how they've grown! Kylie's jubilee: Queen of pop celebrates 25 years Ms Minogue has never been afraid to explore different sides to her persona. No coffee for slugs Gardeners who sprinkle grounds on the soil to deter them break the law
The Independent
2 Derry Street London W8 5TT

© independent.co.uk

Terms & Policies Privacy Policy Cookie policy Code of Conduct Email newsletters RSS Contact us Subscriptions Apps Work for us Evening Standard Homes & Property iJobs Advertising Guide Syndication Novaya Gazeta (English) The Journalism Foundation ES Business Connections Please provide search keyword(s)

Advanced Search Day in a page Article archive © independent.co.uk_cc991.bcp();